Logo for canvasopedia.org
Logo TactisForChange
Dilemma Actions MapCase StudiesMethodsIndexAbout UsContact Us

Apr 1, 2018-2018

India

Distribution of dummy smartphones and fake currency

Share

ACTIVISTS/ACT.GROUPS/DESCRIPTION OF THE GROUP

Shiromani Akali Dal of Punjab

TARGET

The Congress Party of Punjab and Chief Minister of Punjab, Capt. Amrinder Singh

WIDELY HELD BELIEF

The Congress Party and the Chief Minister were not doing enough to improve Punjab’s economic condition, especially unemployment among the young people.

CASE NARRATIVE

Issue and opposition: In Punjab politics, the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) holds a strong position historically. The SAD is a right-leaning party and was formerly a coalition member of the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA). Formed in 1920, it is the second oldest political party in India, the oldest being the Indian National Congress (INC). Since there are other regional political parties with the word “Akali” in their names, the party is referred to as the Shiromani Akali Dal (Badal). Badal was one of the foremost SAD leaders. SAD’s electoral history is checkered despite its contribution to India’s struggle for independence. On 11 March 2017, the INC won the state assembly election, and INC candidate Amarinder Singh became the 15th Chief Minister of Punjab. Amarinder’s tenure was marked with chaos, challenges, fake commitments, and underperformance. This dilemma action was organized by the BJP ally and opposition party SAD members to protest against CM Amarinder Singh and the state Congress Party for their incompetence in governance.
Dilemma Action: On April Fool’s Day of 2018, the SAD distributed dummy smartphones and fake currency to the public to remind them of the fake commitments and promises of Amarinder Singh and his party. State INC had promised that once in power, it would distribute smartphones among Punjab’s youth and create more jobs. None of these promises were kept after Amarinder won the election and became the Chief Minister. This was part of different types of demonstrations and actions against the CM by the opposition party members. April Fool’s Day was chosen to drive the message that the CM and his party were fooling the voters.
Outcome: The opposition party members were able to draw the attention of the public and media to the chaos and inefficiencies of Amarinder Singh’s government in Punjab. Social media platforms especially Twitter took up the story and disseminated the information. Soon, thousands of pdf people were sharing and retweeting this April Fool’s joke. But apart from these, no special concessions were made by the state government although it did provide all a good laugh.

PRIMARY STRUGGLE/GOAL

Accountability / Corruption

DA TACTICS USED

Delivering symbolic objects

CASE NARRATIVE WRITER

SUCCESS METRICS

10 / 12

(CONC) Concessions were made

(MC) Media Coverage

(MSYMP) Media coverage was sympathetic to the activists

(OR) Opponent response

(PS) Dilemma action built sympathy with the public

(PUN) Punishment favored the activists

(REFR) Dilemma action reframed the narrative of the opponent

(RF) Dilemma action reduced fear and/or apathy among the activists

(SA) Dilemma action appealed to a broad segment of the public

Laugtivism

PART OF A LARGER CAMPAIGN

3 / 3

Activist group continued working together after the action

Encouraged more participants to join the movement

Internally replicated by the same movement

RESOURCES

Project documentation

Dilemma Actions Coding Guidebook

Case study documentation

Dilemma_Actions_Analysis_Dataset

CC BY 4.0 Deed, Attribution 4.0 International

SOURCES

Rao, Soumya. 2018. “Post-truth April Fool’s Day: Indian politicians, media and brands struggle to break ‘fake news,’” Retrieved July 23, 2023. (https://scroll.in/article/874069/post-truth-april-fools-day-indian-politicians-media-and-brands-struggle-to-break-fake-news).


Bhardwaj, Nidhi. 2020. “Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha to send dummy smart phone to Punjab CM,” Times of India. Retrieved July 23, 2023. (https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ludhiana/bhartiya-janta-yuva-morcha-to-send-dummy-smart-phone-to-punjab-cm/articleshow/73963763.cms).

Related cases

Jul 15, 2004-2004

India

Naked Mothers in Assam Rifle Protest

Issue and Opposition: Because of insurgents in Manipur, the Indian military is free to apply the Armed Forces Special Powers Act which gives the military unchecked aut...

Human rights
Pro-Democracy
NONVIOLENT PROTEST A...

/

Protest disrobings
Share

Read more

Jan 22, 1905-1905

Russia

To calm economic discontent among the workers, the Russian Minister of the Interior Plehve established a legal trade union in St Petersburg, the Assembly of Russian Fa...

Accountability / Corruption
Economic justice
Human rights
Public Assemblies

/

Assemblies of protes...

Sep 21, 2018-2018

Philippines

Issue and Opposition: By 2018, the Filipinos were tired of the oppression and excesses of Rodrigo Duterte. Duterte served as the 16th Filipino president. His regime la...

Accountability / Corruption
Pro-Democracy
NONVIOLENT PROTEST A...

/

Taunting officials

Subscribe to our newsletters to get full access to all materials on our website.

Logo for canvasopedia.org
Logo TactisForChange
Dilemma Actions MapCase StudiesMethodsIndexAbout UsContact Us

© 2024 Tactics4 Change. All rights reserved. Read our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.