Jan 15, 2012-2012
Russia
Toy Protest in Barnaul
Share
ACTIVISTS/ACT.GROUPS/DESCRIPTION OF THE GROUP
Golos, a Moscow-based independent election watchdog
TARGET
Vlad. Putin; Russian Gov.
WIDELY HELD BELIEF
Protests should continue to happen even if the government does not explicitly allow it, protests allow citizens to hold the government accountable.
CASE NARRATIVE
Issue and Opposition: Putin became acting president after Yeltsin’s resignation in 1999. Within the next few months, he became the president. Due to constitutional constraints on the number of consecutive terms a president can be reelected, Putin assumed power as the prime minister of Russia under President Dmitry Medvedev from 2008 to 2012. After an allegedly rigged election in 2012, Putin came back as president. Putin’s rule ever since has seen the suppression of dissent and opposition besides other excesses. In 2012, led by Golos, a group of protesters and activists participated in a dilemma action against Vladimir Putin and his government.
Dilemma Action: Residents of Barnaul, a Siberian town, organized a unique demonstration. Since under Putin, Article 31 of the Russian Federation Constitution banned public gatherings without official permission (and permission was denied to the protesters time and again), the protesters navigated around the law by putting the posters and placards in the hands of toys. It was a sight to behold. According to news and social media reports, Lego men, plush toys, toy cars, and plastic soldiers stood in lines by the roadside in the snow with signs and banners that had messages such as ‘A thief should sit in jail, not in the Kremlin’. The police officers were seen jotting down notes and details of the toy protesters, making for some fun and amusement among the city residents.
Outcome: The dilemma action drew a lot of international attention. More so, when the Russian prosecutors ruled that in the future, all such toy protests would be banned since the constitution did not allow for toys to hold public meetings, mass gatherings, or rallies. The ruling further emphasized that the toys had committed an illegal act by demonstrating since many of them were produced outside Russia, giving them a foreign status. As imported toys, they could not claim citizenship status. Moreover, the ruling pointed out (in all seriousness) that procedurally toys were not humans and hence, were not eligible to demonstrate in public places.
PRIMARY STRUGGLE/GOAL
NONVIOLENT TACTICS USED
DA TACTICS USED
Camouflaged meetings of protest
CASE NARRATIVE WRITER
SUCCESS METRICS
9 / 12
(MC) Media Coverage
(MSYMP) Media coverage was sympathetic to the activists
(OR) Opponent response
(PS) Dilemma action built sympathy with the public
(PUN) Punishment favored the activists
(REFR) Dilemma action reframed the narrative of the opponent
(RF) Dilemma action reduced fear and/or apathy among the activists
(SA) Dilemma action appealed to a broad segment of the public
Laugtivism
PART OF A LARGER CAMPAIGN
3 / 3
Activist group continued working together after the action
Encouraged more participants to join the movement
Internally replicated by the same movement
RESOURCES
Project documentation
Dilemma Actions Coding Guidebook
Case study documentation
Dilemma_Actions_Analysis_Dataset
SOURCES
Goodman, Jonah. 2023. “Toy Protest — Russia,” Works That Work. Retrieved July 23, 2023. (https://worksthatwork.com/artefacts/toy-protest#:~:text=Toy%20Protest%20%E2%80%94%20Russia%20by%20Jonah%20Goodman%20In,the%20continued%20hegemony%20of%20President%20Vladimir%20Putin%20.).
O’Flynn, Kevin. 2012. “Toys cannot hold protest because they are not citizens of Russia, officials rule,” The Guardian. Retrieved July 23, 2023. (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/feb/15/toys-protest-not-citizens-russia).
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe07049745. Accessed April 15, 2022.
Related cases
Oct 29, 2020-2020
Thailand
Issues and Opposition: The Thailand Monarchy has strict laws against criticism against the royal family. Protestors could be jailed for minor offenses for 10-15 years ...
/
Jan 1, 2008-2008
Canada
Fossil fuel companies disregard human life for profits. A conference of 300 oil company reps was intended to simply focus on more corporate greed. The Yes Men wanted t...
/
Jan 25, 1997-1997
Thailand
The Thai government began planning to build a hydroelectric dam on the Mun River in the early 1980s, and construction began in 1991. The local community had protested ...
/
Subscribe to our newsletters to get full access to all materials on our website.